Skip to main content
New York, NY(212) 365-4875
Clemenza Concierge

Harm from medical care

When the answer came too late

You went in with the headaches, or the lump, or the chest pain. You were told it was stress, or a pulled muscle, or nothing to worry about. By the time someone ran the right test, the news was worse than it would have been months earlier.

Diagnosis errors are among the most common reasons people ask about harm from medical care. They are also among the hardest to judge from the outside, so here is how a lawyer tends to look at them.

Tell us what happened

A wrong answer isn't always a careless one

Doctors aren't expected to be right every time. They are expected to do what a reasonably careful doctor in the same field would have done with the same information: ask the right questions, order the tests the symptoms called for, read the results carefully, and follow up. The question isn't whether the doctor got it wrong, but whether a careful doctor would have got it right, or at least kept looking.

Did the delay change what happened to you

This is often the hardest part. Even if a diagnosis was missed, a claim usually depends on showing that catching it sooner would have made a real difference: a cancer found at an earlier stage, an infection treated before it spread, a stroke caught while treatment could still work. Lawyers call this causation, meaning the link between the mistake and the harm. Doctors reviewing the records are asked to answer it, and the answer shapes everything that follows.

Your timeline is one of the strongest things you can bring

Diagnosis cases turn on what was known and when. Before memories fade, write down each visit as best you remember it: the date, who you saw, what you told them, what they said, and what tests were or were not ordered. Patient portal messages, appointment reminders and pharmacy receipts can help you fill in dates.

  • When the symptoms started, and how they changed.
  • Every visit, call or portal message about them.
  • Tests that were ordered, and when the results came back.
  • When and how the right diagnosis was finally made.

Getting the records

You generally have the right under federal law to a copy of your own medical records, including test results and imaging reports. Ask each provider in writing, keep a copy of your request, and expect that some records will take time. If the patient has died, a family member or the person handling the estate can usually request them.

What helps to have ready

  • Your written timeline of symptoms, visits and tests.
  • The names of every doctor, clinic, urgent care, lab and hospital involved.
  • Test results, imaging reports and patient portal messages you already have.
  • The date and place the correct diagnosis was made.
  • A list of treatment you have had since, and who is treating you now.

Where we fit in

A lawyer at our firm looks at your case. If we take it and another firm is better placed to lead it day to day, we choose that firm from firms we have vetted for their expertise and track record, and we stay responsible for your case with them.

Questions people ask

I saw several doctors. Which one made the mistake?

You don't need to know. Diagnosis cases often involve more than one provider, and sorting out who did what is part of the review.

I only recently learned the diagnosis was missed. Does the time limit start now?

It depends on the state. Some start the clock when the care happened, some when you discovered the problem, and some use a mix. That is one reason to ask a lawyer where the care took place as soon as you can.

My doctor says nothing would have changed. Should I take that as the answer?

Listen carefully, and also know that the question is usually answered by an independent doctor who reviews the full records for the lawyer, not by the doctor whose care is in question.

More about harm from medical care

This page explains things in general terms. It is not legal advice about your situation, and the law differs from state to state.